“Requiem for a Dream” by Darren Aronofsky is a monster when it comes to analyzing editing and montage. Every scene if full of rhythmic editing and unsettling camera work. So, instead of taking 3,000 words to analyze the whole film, I am going to pick two scenes and analyze them alone.

One of the most unnerving scenes in the film for me (and Heather based on the way she was grabbing my arm) was the scene where Sara Goldfarb was watching television, but it quickly transforms as the walls of her house come apart and the host of the show steps out to mock her, with none other than her younger, prettier self.
As the scene progresses, the cuts become faster and faster, like the beating of a heart. We cut back and forth between the ever changing scenery and an extreme close up of Goldfarb’s terrified face. The scene is incredibly disturbing because the viewer can’t grasp anything in it’s entirety. If it was a still camera the scene would still be a little unsettling, but the movie is only able to get the awful effect it does through the genius use of rhythmic and tonal montage.
Along with that, the scene also very clearly breaks the 180 degree rule as the camera spins around the room, capturing every horrible angle as Goldfarb’s mind devolves. The scene is truly heartbreaking and this can only be achieved through monstrous editing.

The final scene of the movie is definitely the most heartbreaking, though. It is pure tonal montage as we cut between the fate of our four main characters and rhythmic montage as each “cycle” climaxes with a jolt into Goldfarb’s head. There is a second rhythm going as well that is a little less… PG-13, but I’ll just say that Marion and her new lady friend keep time rather well. The cuts between the characters get shorter and more frantic as the movie drives to a close and then slows down as Harry loses his arm. I had hope for a happy ending when Sara got checked in, but those hopes were absolutely crushed by this scene. Sara is being tortured by “medicine”, Tyrone is in prison, Marion is at… at a party… and Harry has lost his arm to his heroine addiction.
Then the montage stops, and we see Harry, now through a surgery that would have taken hours probably so we can check modal off the list as well. Then as he sobs we cut to a beach. A boardwalk we saw earlier in the movie that seemed to symbolize the end goal, with woman at the end waiting for a happy ending, but it won’t come. That would be intellectual montage as well, with the boardwalk symbolizing happiness. And that’s how this absolutely tragic roller coaster of emotions ends… yeah big upper that one. Thanks.















